Image default

Proving Theories By way of Outliving Your Critics

Apple Podcasts | Google Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon
Castbox | Stitcher | Podcast Republic | RSS | Patreon


Many individuals have an idealized view of how science works. They assume that somebody makes a discovery or publishes a paper, then everybody acknowledges their discovery, and everybody strikes on to the subsequent factor.


Nevertheless, that isn’t fairly how issues work in actuality. The actual development of science might be fairly messy. One man discovered this the onerous approach.

Be taught extra about J Harlen Bretz and the way he modified a scientific self-discipline via dedication and longevity on this episode of Every little thing In every single place Each day.


The German Nobel Prize-winning physicist Max Planck stated, “A brand new scientific fact doesn’t triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the sunshine, however reasonably as a result of its opponents ultimately die, and a brand new technology grows up that’s accustomed to it.”

Or as it’s extra colloquially put, science advances one funeral at a time. 

Convincing those who deeply held beliefs they maintain are improper may be very troublesome to do. That is true in virtually each facet of life, and science is not any exception.

When a sure worldview is established, overturning it’s onerous, even when the proof is in your facet. 

Nobody knew this higher than J Harlen Bretz. 

Bretz was a highschool biology instructor in Seattle who took an curiosity in geology after which turned that curiosity right into a Ph.D. within the subject, and a educating place on the College of Chicago.

Whereas he was dwelling in Washington, he took an curiosity within the topography of Jap Washington.

In 1922, he started doing fieldwork within the Columbia Plateau and a number of other of the erosional options which had been discovered there. He went to that space yearly for the subsequent seven years, and over a interval of 9 years he revealed 15 papers on the topic. 

He dubbed the world the Channeled Scablands. Should you get an opportunity, as quickly as you might be performed listening to this, do a seek for “Washington Scablands” and check out a number of the photographs to get an thought of what this space seems like. It’s actually spectacular. 

Based on his research, and years spent analyzing the world, he got here to the conclusion that the formations on this area might solely have been carved out by an enormous cataclysmic flood. 

The issue was that the world right now is a excessive desert and there was no apparent supply for the water. 

Little did Bretz know that this principle would devour the subsequent forty years of his life. 

The issue with Bretz’s principle is that it flew within the face of the standard knowledge of the geology institution. 

The predominant worldview of geologists on the time was generally known as gradualism or uniformitarianism. This held that geologic change occurred slowly and steadily over lengthy intervals of time. It had been established by the daddy of recent geology, James Hutton within the 18th century. 

This principle isn’t improper per se. Many geological adjustments occur in precisely this manner. We will so precisely measure the Earth now that we will inform how briskly North American and Europe are drifting away from one another, and how briskly mountains are rising, or shrinking. 

Bretz was proposing a catastrophic change. The concept of catastrophic adjustments like floods, meteor strikes, earthquakes, or hurricanes altering the panorama was anathema to the thought of gradualism. 

In 1927, Bretz gave a presentation to the Geological Society of America in Washington DC. The presentation turned out to be an ambush by established geologists. They packed the room to attempt to shut this concept down for good, and discredit Bretz. 

The main geologists had been largely from elite east coast universities, they didn’t see Bretz as being sufficiently credentialled. In addition they didn’t know the place the water might have come from, and naturally, it upended the largest assumption of their whole self-discipline on the time: gradualism. 

One US Geological Survey scientist named Joseph Pardee sat in on his presentation in Washington and believed what Bretz was saying. He had truly been to the scablands, whereas many of the Bretz’s critics had by no means been there, and by no means even would go to.

Furthermore, he thought he knew the place the water for Bretz’s flood got here from.

The supply of the water, based on Pardee, was a large glacial lake which sat on high of the glacier over Western Montana over the last ice age. The lake was dubbed Glacial Lake Missoula. 

The lake would have had a quantity of water bigger than Lake Ontario, the 4th largest of the Nice Lakes. 

When the glacial ice melted sufficient, the lake began to empty, which brought about a catastrophic flood.  The complete huge quantity of water shot out, and the unbelievable pressure of that water circulation brought about the distinctive options of the scablands. Options, like gigantic 20 meter excessive ripples, which couldn’t have been brought on by gradual erosion over time. 

Over the subsequent a number of many years, the talk raged on. Bretz slowly had youthful geologists settle for his theories, and slowly his critics retired. 

Over time, increasingly more proof supported his principle, and higher understanding of the final ice age developed. 

By the Fifties, sufficient proof had are available that the overall consensus had modified. There have been detailed aerial photographs that grew to become out there. Finally, satellite tv for pc photographs from NASA supplied extra proof.

A few of his critics ultimately did go to the scablands themselves. One critic, James Gilluly commented: “How might anybody have been so improper.”

A 1965 geological report of the area lastly concluded that Bretz was proper all alongside, 40 years after he initially revealed his first paper on the subject.  On the age of 82 he had been vindicated. After the paper got here out, one in every of his critics despatched him a telegram which stated “We’re all now catastrophists.”

Bretz stated concerning the report, “…after 30 years and 30 papers in self-defense, and greater than 30 individuals who vigorously denied my principle, it did my coronary heart good like drugs.”

The ultimate factor which put the cherry on high of Bretz’s achievement occurred in 1979. On the age of 96, he obtained the Penrose Medal from the Geological Society of America. The group’s highest award. 

After receiving the award, he reportedly informed his son, “All my enemies are useless, so I’ve nobody to brag over.”

Bretz handed away in 1981 on the age of 98.

Bretz’s concepts on catastrophism have been broadly accepted now, and it paved the way in which for different theories such because the extinction of the dinosaurs from the Chicxulub crater in Mexico. 

Right this moment, in case you go to Dry Falls State Park in Washington State, on the customer middle you will note a bronze plaque devoted to J Harlen Bretz. On it, is one in every of his quotes from 1928 which says,

“Concepts with out precedent are usually regarded upon with disfavor and males are shocked if their conceptions of an orderly world are challenged.”


The affiliate producer of Every little thing In every single place Each day is Thor Thomson. 

Right this moment’s five-star assessment comes from listener Scott Jordan over on Apple Podcasts. They write:

Probably the most pleasurable podcast- LOVE IT

OMG. I’m addicted. Mainly, it’s a mixture of quick (about 7 min lengthy) and really fascinating tales about historic information informed by Gary Arndt. As soon as I began listening, I couldn’t cease. Earlier than I knew it, I listened to about 10 in a row.

They’re extraordinarily nicely researched and the storytelling is admittedly partaking.

I extremely advocate them. I can’t wait to get caught up after which start listening in actual time.

Nice job Gary!

Thanks Scott. For these of you who don’t know, Scott Jordan is the Scott from Scottevest, the advertisements for whom you’ve heard many occasions on the present. 

Keep tuned in future episodes for one thing particular for Every little thing In every single place listeners.

Related posts

European vs North American Sports activities


Operation Tannenbaum


Mitochondrial Eve


Leave a Comment